Cleaning your room is actually solid advice. You will feel better 10 out of 10 times, i don't see the problem with it
 Tip Your Landlord Shirt $21.68 |
 DMT Has Friends For Me Shirt $21.68 |
Tip Your Landlord Shirt $21.68 |
Cleaning your room is actually solid advice.
Childbrained philosophy
Matthew 18:3
It is very solid advice. It's also advice literally any person would give you if they saw your room. Are Jordan Peterson fans so socially isolated they see basic care as profound?
>fans so socially isolated they see basic care as profound
yes
He's not a father figure, he's a mother figure. He is asking you to do domestic chores
Exactly
That's the state we've gotten to, don't blame JP, blame everyone else
The interesting part he adds to pop culture is the physical mechanism you exploit when you clean up your room that exists in creatures as low as lobsters.
It's not just that your room will be clean, the positive emotional state associated with that and what you learn from completing a task. You get an extra bonus chemical boost from ancient lobster times when you "win" or successfully complete a goal. Sometimes even if the goal is very small like cleaning your room but you have to push your abilities to keep getting the boost.
>Jordan Peterson fans so socially isolated they see basic care as profound?
People need to be reminded more than they need to be taught. The wisest insights are not the most convoluted ones
KEK
As a Muslim I have to say JBP is spot on! I've watched a lot of his lectures including those on the Bible which were fascinating. We have more in common with the israelites and Christians than we are willing to acknowledge and admit. We need to stop hating on them especially the israelites. They are the 'People of the Book'. We need to focus on the positives. PS. I am currently reading the Bible from cover to cover. I also read 12 Rules for Life a few years ago
homie, have some fricking balls. Christian and muslims should join forces, but israelites don't give a frick about us and will keep pushing for a secular and globalized world. You should be proud that muslims are willing to go to war for their beliefs. I wish christians were the same.
it's a comment on one of his older videos
I'm reading the Qur'an cover to cover and we do have a lot in common since we worship tye same Abrahamic God.
This is the lowball lit sarcasm I was told about, right?
>stop regarding christians and israelites as the enemy
ok, now when is he gonna release a message to israelites telling them to stop regarding non-jews as the enemy?
Never. He just got a huge contract to be on Shapiro's platform.
It's literally just proto-"touch grass". He screams it to people who have problems about things bigger than just themselves or not finding their socks
I don't mean to hijack thread but I don't want to create one just for this.
has anyone got any experience with DK History books? picrel looks pretty fun. I'm sure the binding and material used for the book are good but I wonder about its actual historical content/quality.
That book's on sale for about half that on Amazon fyi. But it won't teach you anything. It's essentially a children's atlas made to entertain with historical facts and exotic maps so you have the key associations to learn history from a North American perspective. A good WW2 atlas from National Geographic and the Landmark Thucydides will have everything you can learn from this book.
It’s good advice when feeling down. Do something easy and productive like clean
DARKNESS
IMPRISONING ME
only neets and lazy people seethe with this advice
oops wrong pic
kek coomer predator spotted
>tradlarping /misc/yp collects underaged troony pictures
kek, many such cases
that chicks like 20 she posts on /k/ narcissus or something
Seeing some younger peoples apartments and homes, yeah sometimes you need the very obvious stated to you. Its not profound obviously I dunno if Peterson ever said it was
Yes, it's solid advice. Probably because solid implies it being a rather common fricking thing that 99% of the civilized world does.
For some people mental capacity for organization and discipline in keeping their room clean can translate over into other parts of life and be life changing.
Question is why would people not teach this to their children ASAP
it's delayed gratification, nothing to do with capacity for organization. Motivation, not ability is the key.
>Motivation, not ability is the key.
Depending on motivation is depending on certain sets of thoughts and emotions that you can't control and to experience them every time you should, must or want to do something.
Discipline is acting regardless of emotional state or thought process.
Someone has to take the opposing view: No it's not good advice, cleaning your room for the purposes of solving your depression is not good advice. I have never felt better after cleaning my room, the process itself is always an ordeal because it is a process of mistakes, discovery, inadvertently knocking over things, realizing that to put something on this shelf you first need to do something else, having to fix things that you didn't expect to be broken and generally getting frustrated in pursuit of what was supposed to be an uplifting and purifying experience. Then the follow on effect is now I don't remember where I put my stuff. When I have a pile of papers, I know the exact order of each sheet of paper. When I clean it, I've ruined that memnomic chain and I will always become frustrated as I'm looking for a paper, a tool, a portable harddrive, or whatever I need and being unable to find it because I stupidly decided my space was dirty and needed cleaning some time earlier.
Now I know no one is reading this far and your ADHD motherfrickers are already bashing your emotional and impulsive response, thanks for the (you)s, but this doesn't mean that you shouldn't clean your room ever. I am also well aware of the feedback cycle that exists between living spaces and state of mind, while a messy living space is the consequence of a 'messy' mind, the opposite is also true: keeping your living space organized can help unknott the mental messiness. A accessible and well organized workshop increases productivity, which increases the sense of purpose and satisfaction a person can have.
However if you're cleaning for the purposes of therapy, it will not work.
I believe the Marie Kondo approach of constant tidying is much more superior and healthier in this regard. Firstly it's easier to begin, rather than changing everything in one go. Start small. Obviously the economies of scale begin to work. Secondly a more incremental process is more organic. Top down imposed systems rarely work. If you've ever tried to arrange furniture in a room, you quickly realize how impractical some seemingly logical or aesthetic choices can be. A more iterative approach allows you to organically shape the space based on utility and function (which eliminates the problem of misplacing things after a clean I mentioned earlier).
Cleaning my room in one go has never improved my mood. Tidying however, if taken as a serious commitment over time has helped with more long term improvements in living.
I agree with a lot of what you say but am kind of tired of hearing the clean your room schtick in general and will now rant about it for a bit 'cause no one can stop me.
I watched JP before he became really popular and was very interested in his symbolical exploration of the bible and children cartoons. That was what he did for a long time and that's why I think he doesn't literally mean clean your room at the beginning of him using that line. If I remember correctly it was more meant as "if you want to do something that effects a big group start with the smallest group possible, yourself".
But after a while, as is the case with a lot of interesting things, he became very popular and shit went kind of downhill. Clean your room is taking literally, his daughter is fricking insane, and whatever else you can think of. This reason (and his first book which I bought and read halfway through until I realized and accepted it was fricking awful) I stopped following his life "advice" and became wary of other ideologies too like the Marie Kondo stuff.
Anyway anon, I do agree that doing some cleaning in a more organic structure is a lot better for someone than whatever system whoever is trying to sell you. We are all people and however nice and useful structures might be they don't always work for everyone and should at most be looked at as guidelines so one can grow and make it work for future them as well.
>But after a while, as is the case with a lot of interesting things, he became very popular and shit went kind of downhill.
This is often where the problems begin, it means that even good advice gets taken out of context and oversimplified to the point where it can be counterproductive.
>and that's why I think he doesn't literally mean clean your room at the beginning of him using that line.
Case in point, I haven't read him, I'm making my admitantly contrarian point based on a catchphrase - if he's using it metaphorically to describe starting small. or 'getting your house in order' then that is something that is lost on me. Again, the problem is that he got popular. the message gets diluted. Which means whatever insight or utility it had is lost. And as you say - guidelines and systems are nice but it's not one size fits all - but the popular dilution of things presents it as a one-size-fits all.
This is also why I was careful not to attack him in my post, only the premise of cleaning a room as some kind of therapeutic exercise.
yea i get that it wasn't a critique on him and I guess I'm just struggling to hold onto a past that felt more comfortable and less fricking political. I'm just sad about it anon 🙁
He's obviously riding that wave as long as he can with his second book coming out(or already being released about the same thing).
I usually start by tidying something that's bothering me for some time, and then I see something else that could be tidier and when I come to it I'm cleaning the entire house and I just can't stop.
It's annoying behavior, doesn't happen that often though.
Even Marie fricking Kondo makes a better and deeper argument for cleaning your room.
I wonder how he feels about being the father figure for tens of millions of incels, all on their road to suicide by 30 (it's hilarious they project this on trannies).
I read all his books, 1st is great, these fuels book are mediocre.
Some of his advice is actually quite reasonable.
I hate his fan base
what about washing your penis? and most important of all, could you redpill me on postmodern philosophy, mr peterson?
I've been living in squalor for about three years. It's still fairly messy in here but the kitchen is well organized. Got lots of old useless shit properly recycled. At some point I'll tackle the roll-top desk which contains years worth of old bills, 90% of which I don't need anymore.