The Horse, the Wheel, and Language
The Oxford Introduction to
Proto-Indo-European and the Proto-Indo-European World
Indo-European Language and Culture: An Introduction
and etc etc
all these books, and the Indo-European concept of the Axai social structure and its supposed "origin" or deeper involvement with the PIE has been refuted!
watch this video, the author is a friend of mine and has a degree in history from the University, he prepared all the sources in his video. I discussed it with him on discord, and we maintain that this is just one of the things that refute Eurasian IE hegemony...
the absolute IE theory was already dying since genetics proved that in fact, many "IE expansions" came basically from interaction cultural and not population. (Hittites and others).
I never really believed in it.
But I'm going to watch this shitty video on Youkik3
I don't know much about what's being talked about. sincerely.
But I don't know if YouTube videos are good to base your arguments on.
Do you know him OP? Is he really a historian? I know a guy who is a historian who talks about how the Greeks were multicultural and multiracial.
I don't know if a "historian" values someone
I know.
but the guy in the video is my friend.
he is not biased, he even shows all his sources and his videos are not made without support...
he is educated and has credentials.
The questions ultimately boil down to
broad changes in religious and philosophical thought that occurred in a variety of locations from about the 8th to the 3rd century BCE, to which a "Proto-Indo-European absolute" is attributed about it. and he refutes this idea.
the video is good.
He also destroyed several Afrocentrists on his old channel, but it was deleted lol
checked satan I denounce the talmud
Who is sponsoring his research? Don't drop names but are there others involved?Is he taking money from someone for his work? A historian should always ask this question when engaging with any source, primary or otherwise.
yes to most of your questions.
but according to him, the issue of payment in cash is unfair.
If you want, he has contact with all his work, and always responds to people on YT.
What are you talking about you animal?
Vargs on thumb hahaha
It will be goodz n shiet haha
>been refuted!
yeah lets wait for you to get some papers peer reviewed and published. Youtube videos made by schizos don't prove shit.
Where do I start my love?
Maybe that many of the articles on IE are not peer reviewed? Does this include the books I mentioned?
or who knows, that your evidence is posting a shitty linguistic map from 2018, which DOESN'T EVEN refer to what I'm commenting on?
or could it also be the case that the author of the video is literally an accredited historian? and have you already participated in 6 articles on archeology and mythology?
oh, I almost forgot;
he called 4 of the most famous "members" of Indo-Europeanism to debate live, and none of them accepted the invitation??? grow up. you don't even know what axial is haha
>none of them accepted the invitation
why waste time on a schizo who can't even write a paper to get his supposedly revolutionary ideas considered by his peers in the field? Any nut job can claim they cracked the code to zero point energy or that India is really Atlantis but you will need to do better than some lame youtube video to be taken seriously.
In my hometown, this is called cope.
Brother, the author of the video is a historian and shows all sources in his videos.
He's not a schizo or one of those sensationalist shit videos....
he was even banned from YT for mocking and refuting Afrocentrists. I even posted things about population IQ, etc.
Thank you.
It is ok to question academic status quo because they can be corrupted and lead to stagnation.
But people on the internet took it too seriously and now they believe what any moron with a youtube channel and a cheap degree says, no matter how ridiculous.
like I said above, this guy just licks his historian boyfriend and hasn't posted a single piece of evidence and said that the Hittites weren't Aryans.
he is very arrogant
Frick off reddit
Almost the whole thread is the anti-Germanic Hispanic samegayging with his Google Translated posts. They're all unintelligible and have his trademark linebreak at the beginning.
?
I wonder if this is why European males are usually homosexuals of the receiving kind
You're extremely easy to recognise. I used too much lingo in my post so it came out broken in your machine translation.
comfy we wuz berbers n shiet thread, get in here aryan sisters!
There a million tells giving every post of yours away, removing a single one does nothing.
What's going on ? what do you mean exactly? my post? schizo mârșav
what the frick is "axial"?
>the absolute IE theory was already dying since genetics proved that in fact, many "IE expansions" came basically from cultural interaction and not population. (Hittites and others).
the onus is yours. Why are the Hittites not IE? and what other expansions are false? You just talk and haven't presented a single piece of evidence other than licking your boyfriend.